Suit Blames Gun Flashlight for Dallas Man's Death - NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth

Suit Blames Gun Flashlight for Dallas Man's Death

Plano undercover officer plans to testify in lawsuit against the maker of the SureFire X300 gun-mounted flashlight



    Suit Blames Gun Flashlight for Dallas Man's Death
    NBC 5

    The family of a man who was fatally shot in 2010 by an undercover Plano police officer has filed a lawsuit alleging a badly designed flashlight mounted on the officer's handgun led to the death.

    "It doesn't matter how old your kids are when you lose one it's hard," said Alcala's mother Belinda Saldana.

    Michael Anthony Alcala was shot and killed during an alleged attempt to buy heroin from an undercover officer in the parking lot of a Jack in the Box on the North Dallas Tollway at Frankford Road.

    The officer told investigators he was trying to turn on the gun-mounted SureFire X300 model flashlight when he accidentally fired his weapon, killing the 25-year-old.

    Plano Officer Says He Fired While Trying to Turn on Flashlight

    [DFW] Plano Officer Says He Fired While Trying to Turn on Flashlight
    A Plano police officer says he accidentally killed a drug suspect when he pulled the trigger on his gun while trying to activate his gun-mounted flashlight.
    (Published Friday, Nov. 19, 2010)

    Alcala's family is suing SureFire Holdings, LLC, and SureFire, LLC, charging the California-based companies with defectively and negligently designing the flashlight. The lawsuit, announced Monday, was filed in state court in Orange County, Calif., last week.

    "We hope that Michael Alcala's tragic death will not be completely in vain because ultimately it will lead  to this product being taken off the market so that this tragedy doesn't happen to other families," said the family's attorney Ken Sigelman.

    The Plano officer involved in the shooting is expected to testify in the lawsuit against SureFire.

    Lawsuit Filed Over Accidental Shooting

    [DFW] Lawsuit Filed Over Accidental Shooting
    The family of Michael Alcala have filed a lawsuit against Plano police after an officer accidentally shot a suspect. The officer said he was only trying to turn on his flashlight.
    (Published Tuesday, Dec. 14, 2010)

    A spokesman for SureFire did not immediately return a call or e-mail from the Associated Press seeking comment.

    Dallas police investigated the case and presented it to a Collin County grand jury, which declined to charge the officer.

    Last August, Alcala's family reached a $245,000 settlement with the city of Plano.

    NBC 5's Randy McIlwain contributed to this report.

    Previous Reports:

    Suit Filed in Police Shooting Blamed on Flashlight Mishap
    Officer Blames Fatal Shooting on Trigger Mistake