nbc 5 investigates

Suspected Paper Tag Peddler Shut Down Tuesday, Reopens Wednesday: Investigators

Fraud unit pushes for tougher state laws that identify, fingerprint people applying for car dealer’s licenses in Texas

NBCUniversal, Inc.

Investigators believe a car dealer exposed by NBC 5 Investigates on Monday, suspected of illegally selling paper license tags and then shut down by the state on Tuesday is already operating under a new license.

Law enforcement officials told NBC 5 Investigates on Wednesday the case lays bare major loopholes in a new state law that is supposed to help stop fraudulent car dealers from raking in millions in illegal profits.

In our report Monday we showed how quickly NBC5 Investigates spotted a dozen paper tags in two Dallas neighborhoods printed by a Houston car dealer, Kasniels Auto.  

We knew Kasniels tags were suspicious because of what we learned from a special police unit that investigates paper tag fraud.

“It's wide open. This whole thing is wide open right now, it's wide open,” said Deputy Constable Sgt. Jose Escribano, with the Travis County Constable’s Office, Precinct 3.

Travis County Constables told NBC 5 Investigates they had contacted someone willing to sell them a Kasniels tag online.

An undercover officer gave the seller senior investigative reporter Scott Friedman’s name, a fake VIN and a home address that was really the home of the Dallas Cowboys – AT&T Stadium in Arlington.

The detective did not make the purchase, but the bogus tag was entered in the state's system by someone using Kasniels’ dealer license.

DMV records we obtained show Kasniels has printed more than 73,000 paper tags this year.

Investigators said there's no way the company, which claimed to operate from a tiny car lot in Houston, really sold 73,000 cars.

They believe the company is selling tags for profit.

One day after our report aired, the Texas DMV told us it revoked Kasniels’ dealer’s license.

But then Wednesday, just one day later, another twist.

“They shut this one down. They activate one of their other ones. And here we go again,” Escribano said.

Travis County investigators told NBC 5 Investigates they bought a paper tag Wednesday morning from a dealer called Southwest Autos LLC and they said their investigation found the person selling Southwest tags also sold Kasniels tags.

Proof, they said, the state needs to identify people applying for dealer’s licenses in-person and fingerprint them to stop fraudsters from operating under multiple business names.

“The party would be over for them, because now I've got the person at the other end. I've got a physical person that I can go and have a conversation with,” said Escribano.

Under a new state law that went into effect in September, the DMV Board is currently in the process of writing new rules to curb paper tag fraud.  But even under the new proposed rules the agency would still have to wait 10 days to shut down a dealer suspected of fraud.

That’s too much time, investigators fear, for bad actors to keep selling tags and obtaining a new license under another name.

“We would want them shut down now. Like right now, pull the plug right? This second,” said Escribano.

Wednesday, the Texas DMV told NBC 5 Investigates it is actively investigating Southwest Autos LLC.

In a statement they said, "the department does not have authority under state law to fingerprint applicants. However, the department is continuing to explore additional steps."

We reached out to a phone number Southwest Autos provided to the DMV. The person who responded to our message told us they have no connection to Southwest Autos.

Messages sent to Kasniels have not been returned.

The DMV told NBC 5 Investigates it does take steps to see if people who own dealerships are connected to other dealers. But as we previously reported, the DMV also allows car dealers to add authorized users to their accounts -- people who can print tags in the state system but are not vetted.

Investigators we spoke to said that needs to change and anyone who can access the system should be thoroughly vetted by state officials.

Contact Us