New Look at Old Prostate Cancer Treatment

Prostate cancer is the second leading cause of cancer death among American men.

Patients have several different treatment options, including two types of internal radiation therapy: low-dose rate brachytherapy or high–dose rate brachytherapy. Both involve having radioactive seeds implanted near the tumor. 

For years, very few patients took advantage of the high-dose option, but that may begin to change.

Greg Hildebrand, 64, didn’t want to be sidelined for long after getting this good news/bad news message from his doctor.

“'Mr. Hildebrand, unfortunately we found cancer, but not to worry, this is readily treatable,” recalled Hildebrand of the conversation he had with his doctor.

To treat his prostate cancer, Hildebrand went with a procedure called high-dose rate brachytherapy. Unlike the low-dose rate radiation treatment, which permanently implants radioactive seeds directly into the prostate, the high-dose rate radiation is removed the same day.

“The radiation is delivered right then and there later that day as opposed to having a permanent source inside you that slowly delivers the radiation over six to eight months,” Abhishek Solanki, M.D., radiation oncologist at Loyola University Medical Center in Chicago explained.

Hildebrand received two treatments over two weeks. His side effects lasted only one month.

Doctors say complications from the low-dose-rate treatment can last six months.

“It’s cleaner. It’s more direct. It’s less intrusive,” detailed Hildebrand.

HDR was clearly the better option for him, so how come not all doctors have embraced it?

“One of the reasons why is, from a resource perspective, for the staff and clinic, it’s a little bit harder,” said Solanki.

But for some patients, it may be the key to good health

Solanki said more doctors are starting to consider high-dose rate radiation brachytherapy as a treatment option now that there are 10-year studies showing it is just as effective as the low-dose rate treatment and the cancer doesn’t return in 80 to 90 percent of patients in a certain risk group.

A study by the Cleveland Clinic found that brachytherapy was the cheapest of all treatments for prostate cancer with an average cost of $2,500.

Brachytherapy is used only in patients whose cancer has not spread to other organs.

Contact Us