College Student Says Car Engine Had No Oil, Hours After Getting An Oil Change - NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth
NBC 5 Responds

NBC 5 Responds

Responding to your consumer needs and connecting you to your money

College Student Says Car Engine Had No Oil, Hours After Getting An Oil Change

The young man had to buy a new engine for his car, costing several thousand dollars

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    A young man who had his oil changed at a Walmart service center said the check engine light soon came on, and no oil was on the dipstick. After not receiving any financial help from a claim to Walmart, the family spent about $8,000 on a new engine. (Published Thursday, Sept. 21, 2017)

    When Jose Betances saved up to buy his first new car his father made it clear to him it was more than just a set of wheels.

    "I know that there's a certain amount of maintenance and follow up with the car, something as simple as an oil change," Betances said.

    He had that done recently at Walmart in Frisco, on Farm-to-Market Road 42. His now 2-year-old Ford Focus got a clean bill of health when he picked up the car.

    "When I was given the invoice, all I saw was 'good, good, good, good and good,'" Betances said.

    Elderly Texas Couple Survives 6 Days in Desert

    [DFW] Elderly Texas Couple Survives 6 Days in Desert

    An elderly couple from Houston was rescued after spending six days stranded in a remote desert area of southern Utah.
     

    (Published Monday, Oct. 16, 2017)

    He said he drove straight home, and later that night, drove to visit a friend who, he said, lives minutes away.

    "All of a sudden my check engine light comes on," Betances said.

    He said he pulled over and turned the car off and back on, and the check engine light went out. Betances got back on the road again. He said moments later, the entire dashboard lit up.

    "It was telling me that my passenger bag had been deployed, telling me I had to change the battery, the oil, I had low tire pressure," Betances said. "Every signal that you can think of was on at the same time. Next step, I have no acceleration and I can't accelerate on the car."

    He stopped again and called his Dad, Jose Betances Sr.

    "There's no damage, so something told me just take the oil stick out, and I took it out. It's completely dry," his father said.

    Web Extra: Future Pilot Pops The Question Mid-Flight

    [DFW] Web Extra: Future Pilot Pops The Question Mid-Flight

    A Collin County Couple is celebrating a big milestone in their relationship. After dating for a year and seven months, Nick Cannan was ready to take the next step with Karryn Beattie.

    (Published Monday, Oct. 16, 2017)

    The next morning, a Walmart mechanic drove out to the car and the family said he confirmed there was no oil inside the engine.

    The men met with a Walmart manager, filled out a claims form asking Walmart to cover the repairs. They were told an investigation would be launched.

    Soon after, a letter came from Walmart's claims investigator.

    The Betanceses wouldn't be receiving any money back. The letter goes on to say Walmart wasn't negligent and even added, "some medical plans refuse payment of bills related to this type of situation."

    That particular line confused the family, who wanted to know about an oil change, not medical bills.

    They wrote back, but were told again, their claim was denied.

    Letter Finally Delivered 62 Years Late

    [DFW] Letter Finally Delivered 62 Years Late

    A letter mailed in 1955 has finally been delivered to Detroit resident Allen Pearlman, thanks in part to the family now living in his childhood home. 

    (Published Monday, Oct. 16, 2017)

    NBC 5 Responds reached out to Walmart, who provided us this statement:

    "We work hard to maintain a high standard of customer service and satisfaction for everyone who shops with us. After speaking with the associates involved and reviewing surveillance video, it was determined that all procedures related to this oil change were properly followed."

    We asked to see the video, if Walmart was certain oil was added, and if the drain was plugged tightly after the service.

    Walmart wouldn't show NBC 5 the video, but said, "We can confirm oil was put in the car. There is no video angle showing the drain plug being reinstalled."

    The Betanceses said they were given no further explanation, and a new engine cost them about $8,000.

    Walmart did tell us the Betanceses were entitled to a copy of the full report into their investigation.

    Cute Alert! Tiny Spider Monkey Born at Chester Zoo

    [DFW] Cute Alert! Tiny Spider Monkey Born at Chester Zoo

    The Colombian Black-Headed spider monkey was born Monday to 29-year-old spider monkey, Christine, and her 28-year-old mate Popoyan at England's Chester Zoo. At just a few days old, the baby is yet to be named as keepers do not yet know its gender.

    (Published Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2017)

    They repeatedly asked for it via email, copying us on the requests. They have yet to receive that report.

    We asked, too, and after more than four weeks, it has not arrived.


    Do you have a story idea? We want to hear from you! Fill out the complaint form on the NBC 5 Responds page or call 844-5RESPND, (844) 573-7763. More #NBC5Responds archive here.