Texas County Threatened With Lawsuit Over COVID-19 Order

Efforts by officials in one South Texas county to delay the start of face-to-face classes due to the coronavirus pandemic could face a legal challenge on claims of religious freedom.

Cameron County, which has been one of the many COVID-19 hot spots in South Texas in recent months, has delayed in-person classes at public and private K-12 schools until after Sept. 28.

But attorneys for two private religious schools have told the county that the order is unlawful and goes against Republican Gov. Greg Abbott's June 26 executive order superseding the authority of local governments to issue orders aimed at slowing the spread of the coronavirus if they conflict with the governor's own orders, the Brownsville Herald reported.

Laguna Madre Christian Academy in Laguna Vista and Calvary Christian School of Excellence in Harlingen plan to open for face-to-face classes on Aug. 31 and Sept. 8, respectively.

Last month, Abbott said Texas counties don't have the power to preemptively shut down campuses to stop the spread of the coronavirus. Abbott said that power rests with local school boards and state education officials.

Jeremy Dys, an attorney with Plano-based First Liberty, which represents the two schools, told officials in a letter that "any effort by Cameron County to enforce its unlawful order . will be viewed as an affront to the religious liberty of (the two schools) and met with the strictest legal defense."

Daniel N. Lopez, an attorney for Cameron County, said in an Aug. 20 letter that officials were not opposed to granting Laguna Madre Christian Academy an exemption because the school is small and it came up with a plan that meets state guidelines for reopening.

Coronavirus Pandemic

Full coverage of the COVID-19 outbreak and how it impacts you

Marriages in the US are back to pre-pandemic levels, CDC says

But Calvary Christian School is bigger and its reopening plan was still being reviewed, officials said.

Cameron County Judge Eddie Trevino Jr. said First Liberty is misconstruing the county's order regarding schools as an attack on religious freedom.

"This is not a political or religious issue. This is health and safety and protection of our children issue. I don't understand their rationale in wanting to put their children and teachers at risk, but I guess that's their decision to make -- not one I would make," said Trevino, the county's top elected official.

Copyright AP - Associated Press
Contact Us