What We Learned from Gates-Crowley Flap

We are all part-Irish exiles in the land of picnic tables

By SARA K. SMITH
Updated 3:40 AM CDT, Thu, Jul 30, 2009

TWITTER FACEBOOK

There are no heroes or villains in this story -- just three ordinary men trying to enjoy a beer outdoors, if weather permits.
Getty Images

Today will mark an incredibly important and solemn moment in the annals of interhuman diplomacy, for it is the day that President Obama brings together a police officer and a professor over carefully selected beers to talk about their feelings.

Nearly two weeks ago, Cambridge police sergeant James Crowley arrested Professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. on his front porch. Since then we have learned so many things -- about life, and love, and racial harmony, and proper police procedure, and how a single randy fourth-century Irishman was indirectly responsible for this whole event!

[Gates] went to Trinity College in Dublin to have his DNA analyzed. There he found that he shared 10 of the 11 DNA matches with offspring of Niall of the Nine Hostages, the fourth century warlord who created one of the dominant strains of Irish genealogy because he had so many offspring.
Ironically, James Crowley, whose name in Gaelic means "hardy warrior," is also descended from the same line as Gates, having very close links to Niall of the Nine Hostages.

So if you want to blame somebody for Gates-gate, you might as well start with this Niall character rather than poor Lucia Whalen, whose 911 call revealed her not to be a racially paranoid busybody but rather a vaguely concerned citizen who wasn't even sure there was a crime taking place when she called the cops.

And if you're looking for somebody to feel outraged at, why not start with our president, Barack Obama? He might not even let his honored White House guests indoors!

[W]eather permitting, the three men will meet at a picnic table outside the Oval Office.

Imagine if Germany and the Allies came to Versailles to sign the treaty ending World War I and were told, "Enh, skip the Hall of Mirrors! Let's just go sign it in the back yard, over some beers." That is approximately the level of offense we're talking about here.

May the picnic table beer summit be the end of an era of misunderstanding, and not the beginning of an era of insult.

Etiquette expert Sara K. Smith writes for NBC and Wonkette.

First Published: Jul 29, 2009 8:54 AM CDT

TWITTER FACEBOOK

  • 83% furious 5
  • 17% sad 1
  • 0% bored 0
  • 0% thrilled 0
  • 0% intrigued 0
  • 0% laughing 0
processing
      No comments have been posted yet.

      You have 2000 characters left

      processing
      So My City

      You are posting in (change)

      550/550 characters

      (jpg, pngs, or gifs allowed)

      (jpg, pngs, or gifs allowed)
      *Tip: You can also post moments via email or Twitter.

      processing

      View Your Moment in

      Posted by | 1 second ago

      Don't Miss

      business

      Mar 21, 2010

      Some North Texans Bailing on Big Banks

      Some banking customers are opting to say hello to a local option.

      Read It

      politics

      42 minutes ago

      The House Passed the Overhaul — Now What?

      On Tuesday, the Senate is expected to start their work on the fixes bill using reconciliation. For Democrats, the process is the perfect antidote to what they perceive as GOP obstructionism.

      Read It

      celebrity

      46 minutes ago

      Photos: The Tiger Woods Scandal

      The world's No. 1 golfer prepares to return to the sport that made him famous after revelations about his personal life rendered him a recluse.

      Loading...
      Birthdate:
      You must be at least 13 to sign up.
      Gender:
      invalid

      By clicking the button below, I accept the terms of use and privacy policy

      Already Signed Up? Login Below.

      processing

      Here's what we're posting:

      *Only used for verification. We do not store your password.
      processing