State Supreme Court to Hear Pet-Value Appeal | NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth

News from around the state of Texas

State Supreme Court to Hear Pet-Value Appeal

Judge to hear argument on considering sentimental value of a pet when computing damages


    Sentimental value or market value?

    The Texas Supreme Court will hear arguments on whether a judge or jury should consider the sentimental value of a pet instead of its market value when it comes to computing damages.

    The Fort Worth Star-Telegram reports justices have accepted the appeal of an appeals court ruling that overturned a 120-year-old Texas Supreme Court precedent. The 2nd Texas Court of Appeals in Fort Worth ruled that owners can claim the sentimental value of their dead pets.

    Kathryn and Jeremy Medlen sued a former Fort Worth animal shelter employee after their dog was mistakenly euthanized three years ago.

    A state district judge initially dismissed their sentimental value claim, but the appeals court reversed that decision.

    Arguments are set for Jan. 10.