MedStar: No Change to Red Lights, Sirens

Ambulance service finds device to change traffic lights doesn't improve response times

View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print

    NEWSLETTERS

    After a unique experiment to speed response times and improve safety, Fort Worth's ambulance service has decided to keep using old-fashioned lights and sirens instead of a device that remotely turns red lights green.

    For two months, MedStar equipped two ambulances with Opticom and conducted an experiment.

    After Experiment, MedStar to Stay With Lights, Sirens

    [DFW] After Experiment, MedStar to Stay With Lights, Sirens
    Fort Worth's ambulance service MedStar found that a device that remotely turns red lights green did not improve response times. (Published Thursday, Nov 17, 2011)

    Opticom is a traffic control system that sends a signal from emergency vehicles to turn traffic lights green.

    "Lights and sirens are very disruptive to normal traffic flow," said MedStar supervisor Shaun Curtis. "People are more apt to stop at a red light than they would for an ambulance coming through the intersection."

    Larger Waistlines Mean Bigger Ambulances

    [DFW] Larger Waistlines Mean Bigger Ambulances
    Medstar is replacing its fleet to accommodate the growing number of overweight patients. (Published Tuesday, Feb 22, 2011)

    The idea was to still use lights and siren for life-threatening calls such as heart attacks. MedStar conducted the experiment with Opticom on lower-priority calls, such as most traffic accidents.

    But after looking at the results, MedStar found Opticom didn't increase response times at all.

    Medstar Flipping Off Sirens for Cardiac Arrest Patients

    [DFW] Medstar Flipping Off Sirens for Cardiac Arrest Patients
    Ambulances in Fort Worth will no longer race to the hospital with lights and sirens while transporting people in cardiac arrest. (Published Friday, Apr 16, 2010)

    The average response time was two-and-a-half minutes per mile with it -- the same as using red lights and sirens.

    "I was very surprised by the results," Curtis said. "I really thought that being able to manipulate the lights would significantly improve our response time."

    MedStar has decided not to use Opticom and continue using lights and sirens.

    "The experiment is over for now," he said.

    Curtis speculated that part of the problem is that not all red-light intersections in Fort Worth are equipped with Opticom.

    As Fort Worth adds more traffic lights to the system and technology improves, MedStar might try the experiment again in the future, he said.